Friday, August 19, 2011

Stupid Question Regarding Swords & Wizardry "CL" vs. AD&D/OSRIC "Dungeon Level"

So I'm trying to hack out some over the top OSR monster book encounter tables (utilizing the monsters from the Swords & Wizardry Monster Book AND Monsters of Myth AND Malevolent and Benign AND Tome of Horrors Complete AND the indices from the AD&D Monster Manual II), starting with the dungeons, and I have a pretty stupid question for folks that are Swords & Wizardry AND AD&D/OSRIC mavens...

For AD&D/OSRIC monsters are arranged on a "Dungeon Level" scale from 1/I to 10/X BUT Swords & Wizardry uses a Challenge Level system without a cap that extends waaay past 10/X.

Is there any quick rules of thumb regarding converting S&W CL to AD&D/OSRIC "Dungeon Level" or am I just being obtuse/overthinking this? I'm actually way stupider than usual lately so please bear with me.


6 comments:

  1. I don't think there's much difference in how these are used or how they correspond to the dungeon level. Check out the tables on page 93 of S&W, and you should be able to break down the correspondence between CL and dungeon level so that it is analogous to the AD&D/OSRIC system.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you have access to Castles & Crusades, it has a system for generating a monster's AD&D style "level." It might be worth doing on the S&W monsters. Conversely you might want to try converting the AD&D monsters to the S&W system.

    That might be too much work so you might just wanna say "fuck it" and assume they're roughly equivalent.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I prefer to use this approach when sizing monsters for encounters, based on BECMI -- create each encounter to have monsters with 1/2 the hit dice of the party. See the discussion on this vs. CR here: http://www.swordsandwizardry.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=3427

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think most creatures in S&W would be in AD&D anyway, so maybe you could just use the rating they have in AD&D?

    As far as I can gather from p93 of my copy of the 'Core Rules' version, a Challenge Level by itself doesn't determine what dungeon level the monster will be found on.

    For example CL3 creatures can be found on levels 1 to 6. On level 1 there'll be one of them, on level 6 there'll be 16d6 of them.

    So if you want to have a monster only exist on one level, I'd start by deciding how many of them are encountered, then find the entry that's closest to that.

    For example for a CL4 creature that's encountered in groups of 2-8, you might put them on level 4 (the table has 2d6 CL4 creatures on level 4).

    ReplyDelete
  5. The issue is that between all of my OSR monster books I have about 1500 monsters split between S&W and OSRIC so I'm not going to be doing any real number crunching.

    However I did some comparisons between monsters in both systems and I think I'm hacking together a CL/Level conversion algorithin.

    ReplyDelete
  6. When it comes to Radon Testing Pocahontas, we know it is crucial to decide because first thing is that it is a very alarming situation when you feel like the air around is making you and your family sick but one thing that concerns the home owners is to let someone inside their house. The security of the house is the first thing that comes in the minds of the residents when it is about letting a stranger come inside your house and inspect everything in detail. We understand that you need to be 100% sure yourself before trusting someone else completely with the privacy of your home. When we talk about a trusted Home inspector Pocahontas IL, Hawley tops the list with their multiple certifications from InterNACHI, CRT, ASHI and BBB. They have the best professionals certified by the state and with great positive reviews and are rated A+ by better business bureau. So why hesitate before booking an appointment? Book yours today to get it tested for radon.

    ReplyDelete